UniverCell Logo

Original vs. Aftermarket Screens: What You Need to Know Before Repairing Your Phone

May 15, 2025 · 10:01 AM EDT|Repair

Has your phone screen cracked? You're not alone. Screen damage is one of the most common issues smartphone users face, and choosing the right replacement screen can make a significant difference in your device's performance.


Your phone's screen serves as your window to the digital world. It's how you:

  1. Read messages and emails
  2. Watch videos and photos
  3. Navigate apps and websites
  4. Play games
  5. Connect with loved ones

When it comes to screen repairs, you have two main options: original (OEM) screens or aftermarket alternatives. Each choice comes with its own set of considerations that can impact your phone's:

  1. Display quality
  2. Touch responsiveness
  3. Battery life
  4. Long-term durability

At UniverCell Canada, we understand the importance of making an informed decision about your screen replacement. If you're in need of professional smartphone repair, our Danforth location in Toronto offers top-notch services. Let's explore the key differences between original and aftermarket screens to help you choose the best option for your needs and budget.

Understanding Screen Types

When it comes to phone repairs, there are two main types of screens you'll come across: OEM and aftermarket screens. Let's take a closer look at each of them.

  1. OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) Screens

OEM screens are the real deal - they're made by the same manufacturers who produced your phone in the first place. Whether it's Apple, Samsung, or Google, these companies ensure that their screens meet the highest quality standards.

Here are some key characteristics of OEM screens:

  1. Manufactured under strict quality control standards
  2. Perfect fit with your device's dimensions
  3. Identical touch sensitivity and response
  4. Same color calibration as original screen
  5. Built with genuine components

Think of OEM screens as identical twins to your phone's original screen - they're made in the same factories, using the same materials and specifications. If you want to restore your device to its former glory with an exact replacement, OEM screens are the way to go.


  1. Aftermarket Screens

Aftermarket screens are produced by third-party manufacturers as alternatives to OEM parts. While they may look similar to your original screen, there can be variations in quality and performance.

Here's what sets aftermarket screens apart:

  1. Produced by independent manufacturers
  2. Reverse-engineered to match original specifications
  3. Available in different quality grades
  4. Made with varying materials and components
  5. Often feature modified designs to avoid patent issues

Think of aftermarket screens as the generic medicine equivalent in the phone repair world. They serve the same basic function but might differ in subtle ways from the original. These screens have become increasingly popular due to their accessibility and cost-effectiveness, filling a crucial gap in the repair market where OEM parts might be scarce or cost-prohibitive.


The quality of aftermarket screens can vary significantly based on the manufacturer. Some premium aftermarket producers invest heavily in research and development, creating screens that closely match OEM quality. Others focus on producing budget-friendly options that prioritize basic functionality over premium features.


If you're located in Longueuil, Quebec, you can find high-quality device repairs at UniverCell, a premier gadget repair center known for its excellent service.

Pros and Cons of OEM Screens

OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) screens have their own pros and cons that can affect your decision on whether to repair or not.

Advantages of OEM Screens:

  1. Superior Material Quality: OEM screens are made with high-quality materials, undergo strict quality control, have precise color calibration, and are built to last.
  2. Comprehensive Warranty Protection: With an OEM screen, you get full manufacturer coverage, protection against defects, access to authorized repair services, and guaranteed replacement options.
  3. Consistent Performance: OEM screens are designed to work perfectly with your device's software, providing optimal touch sensitivity, accurate color reproduction, and reliable brightness levels.

Disadvantages of OEM Screens:

  1. Cost Considerations: OEM screens tend to be more expensive than other options, with prices 30-50% higher. Additionally, there may be extra installation fees and higher insurance deductibles to consider.
  2. Limited Availability: OEM screens may not be easily accessible as they are distributed through specific channels. This could result in longer waiting times for repairs and limited options for where you can get the screen replaced.

When deciding whether to go for an OEM screen or not, it's important to weigh these factors against your own needs. While you can expect top-notch quality and performance from an OEM screen, it does come at a higher price. Additionally, if time is a critical factor for you, the limited availability of OEM screens may impact how quickly you can get your device repaired.

Pros and Cons of Aftermarket Screens

Aftermarket screens are a great option for phone owners on a budget. Let's take a look at their advantages and disadvantages.

Pros

  1. Cost-Effective Solutions: Aftermarket screens typically cost 40-60% less than OEM alternatives
  2. Wide Availability: Multiple suppliers offer quick access to replacement parts
  3. Diverse Quality Options: Choose from various price points to match your budget
  4. Immediate Availability: No waiting for authorized dealer stock

Cons

  1. Inconsistent Quality: Screen quality can vary significantly between manufacturers
  2. Display Performance: Users might experience:
  3. Reduced brightness levels
  4. Less vibrant color reproduction
  5. Different touch sensitivity
  6. Potential screen ghosting issues

Technical Variations

  1. Screen thickness may differ from OEM specifications
  2. Color calibration might not match original display standards
  3. Touch response can feel different from the original screen

Many aftermarket manufacturers have improved their production standards, offering mid-tier options that balance quality and affordability. Some premium aftermarket screens now include advanced features like:

  1. Oleophobic coating for fingerprint resistance
  2. Enhanced scratch protection
  3. Improved color accuracy

When selecting an aftermarket screen, research specific manufacturers and read user reviews for your phone model. The right aftermarket screen can provide satisfactory performance while keeping repair costs manageable.


Visual Performance Comparison between OEM and Aftermarket Screens


Let's dive into the specific visual differences between OEM and aftermarket screens through measurable performance metrics:

Color Accuracy

  1. OEM screens typically achieve 95-100% color accuracy
  2. Aftermarket alternatives range from 70-90% accuracy
  3. Noticeable variations in white balance and color temperature
  4. Professional users might spot subtle tinting in aftermarket displays

Brightness Levels

  1. OEM screens reach maximum brightness of 500-1000 nits
  2. Aftermarket options often cap at 400-800 nits
  3. Sunlight readability can be compromised on aftermarket displays
  4. Auto-brightness features may respond differently on non-OEM screens

Display Resolution

  1. OEM screens maintain consistent pixel density
  2. Some aftermarket displays show slight pixelation
  3. Text clarity differences become apparent during reading
  4. Video playback quality variations are noticeable in high-definition content

Touch Response

  1. OEM screens offer 120Hz-144Hz touch sampling rates
  2. Aftermarket alternatives typically provide 60Hz-90Hz
  3. Gaming and fast-scrolling experiences show performance gaps
  4. Multi-touch gestures might require firmer pressure on aftermarket screens

Viewing Angles

  1. OEM displays maintain color consistency at various angles
  2. Aftermarket screens often show color shifting beyond 30-degree angles
  3. Contrast ratios decrease more rapidly in non-OEM options
  4. Screen visibility in different lighting conditions varies significantly


These performance metrics directly impact your daily phone usage, from casual browsing to professional photo editing. The differences become particularly apparent when viewing high-quality media content or using your device in challenging lighting conditions.

Making the Right Choice for Your Repair Needs

Choosing between OEM and aftermarket screens requires a personalized approach based on your specific circumstances. Let's break down the key factors to consider:

  1. Budget Assessment
  2. Set a realistic budget range for your repair
  3. Factor in the device's age and planned duration of use
  4. Consider the resale value impact of your screen choice


  1. Usage Patterns Matter
  2. Heavy users benefit from OEM durability
  3. Light users might find aftermarket screens sufficient
  4. Professional users requiring color accuracy should prioritize OEM


  1. Device Value Considerations
  2. High-end flagship phones deserve premium OEM screens
  3. Mid-range devices allow flexibility in screen choice
  4. Older models might justify aftermarket alternatives


  1. Personal Priorities
  2. Display quality enthusiasts should invest in OEM
  3. Budget-conscious users can explore quality aftermarket options
  4. Consider your device's remaining lifespan


A practical approach is matching your screen choice to your device's value - spending $300 on an OEM screen for a $400 phone might not make financial sense. Your daily phone usage patterns should guide this decision. Professional photographers or digital artists need perfect color reproduction, while casual users might be satisfied with a quality aftermarket display.


Remember: your choice affects both immediate satisfaction and long-term device performance. Balance your immediate budget constraints with long-term usage plans to make an informed decision.

Recommendations for Consumers Seeking Phone Screen Repairs

Finding a reliable repair service is crucial for a successful screen replacement. Here's what to look for when choosing a repair provider:

  1. Check repair certifications - Professional technicians should hold relevant certifications and demonstrate expertise in handling your specific device model
  2. Read customer reviews - Look for detailed feedback about screen repair experiences, particularly focusing on long-term satisfaction
  3. Ask technical questions - Reputable repair shops will:
  4. Explain the differences between available screen options
  5. Provide warranty information
  6. Detail their repair process
  7. Share their quality control measures
  8. Request screen samples - Many professional services can demonstrate the visual differences between OEM and aftermarket options before you commit
  9. Verify parts sourcing - Professional repair centers maintain relationships with reliable suppliers and can trace their screen components


Remember to document your device's condition before repair and keep all service receipts. A trustworthy repair center will offer post-repair support and stand behind their workmanship with a solid warranty policy.


The choice between OEM and aftermarket screens shapes your device's future performance, visual quality, and reliability. Both options bring distinct advantages to the table - OEM screens offer premium quality and guaranteed compatibility, while aftermarket alternatives provide cost-effective solutions without compromising basic functionality.


Your decision should align with your specific needs:

  1. Budget-conscious users might find aftermarket screens a practical choice
  2. Performance enthusiasts often benefit from investing in OEM components
  3. Long-term device users should weigh durability against immediate cost savings


Ready to make an informed decision about your screen repair? The expert technicians at UniverCell Canada are here to guide you through your options. With over a decade of experience and 25,000+ successful repairs, we'll help you choose the perfect screen solution for your device.


Visit your nearest UniverCell Canada location or contact us today - let's bring your device back to life with a screen repair that matches your expectations and budget. Be sure to review our terms and conditions for more information on our policies regarding returns, warranties, and other important aspects.


FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

What are OEM screens?

OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) screens are produced by the device manufacturers themselves. They guarantee quality and compatibility with the original device specifications, ensuring that the performance of your phone remains consistent.

What are aftermarket screens?

Aftermarket screens are produced by third-party companies as alternatives to OEM screens. They offer a variety of options but may vary in quality and performance compared to original manufacturer screens.

What are the advantages of using OEM screens?

The advantages of OEM screens include high-quality materials, warranty benefits, and performance consistency. They are designed to meet the original specifications of your device, ensuring optimal functionality.

What are the disadvantages of aftermarket screens?

The disadvantages of aftermarket screens include quality variability and potential issues with performance, such as reduced brightness or color accuracy. It's important to research specific aftermarket options before making a choice.

How should I choose between OEM and aftermarket screens for my repair needs?

When choosing between OEM and aftermarket screens, consider your budget against the desired quality. Personal preferences also play a significant role in your decision-making process. Weighing these factors will help you make an informed choice.

Where can I find trusted repair services for phone screen replacements?

For reliable phone screen repairs, it's advisable to seek professional repair services that can provide expert advice on both OEM and aftermarket options. UniverCell Canada is recommended as a trusted destination for phone repairs.